I have just signed up to LastPass Premium ($55 pa) rather than BW Premium ($10 pa) because BitWarden’s keyboard shortcuts are so truly awful.
Three and a half years since this simple, basic feature was requested:
“the most common functions should be easily acheived using keyboard”.
In response, the devs have provided little more than an emoji of a man wearing sunglasses.
I agree that something seems to be quite badly wrong in some respects with the way the team is prioritising responses to community feedback. This is such low-hanging fruit which is easy to fix that it’s crazy it has not been addressed in years.
Hi Anthony - welcome. Custom keyboard shortcuts for the Bitwarden clients is still in development, so unfortunately you can’t change the shortcut for the Bitwarden extension yet.
Why I have done as a workaround is change the mapping for the Safari app so that CMD-L both opens and hides the sidebar (System Preferences → Keyboard → Shortcuts → App Shortcuts → add entry for Safari.app). Then there is no conflict, even if the method is not exactly ideal.
I am also going to move your post to the main thread so it lends more support to the main request. Cheers!
It seems that the most wanted shortcut for every browser and platform (and especially for those coming from LastPass) is a login shortcut.
In LP, you just hit
Enter at the selected item and you are redirected to the website login form, which is autofilled for you. Instead, in BW,
Enter simply opens a dialog displaying the entry content (username, pw, etc.). Something that you rarely want.
Of course, there are several other shortcuts that we would like to have, but if you think like me that this is the most annoying lack, I have opened a separate request here.
Please, upvote my post, if you agree. Hopefully, if developers focus on a single shortcut, they could get the job done, while asking for multiple shortcuts is a plea for an infinite delay.
In the meantime, for me, the only viable solution is the old school KeePassXC.
I found this request and it should be merged here as this one did.
I really hate the current behaviour of overriding the default keymap. I want to use Command+Shift+L as opening side bar, which is a default keymap on Safari, but Bitwarden takes it. I was forced to set the other key. I wish I could just turn off the keymapping of Bitwarden.
The keyboard shortcuts like ‘CMD+SHIFT+L’ are conflicting with the default keyboard shortcuts in Safari. With the latest version of safari 15 there are more shortcuts conflicting.
Please make the keyboard shortcuts editable so we can use the default Safari keyboard shortcuts the way they are meant to be (of course I know about a workaround creating custom keyboard shortcuts for Safari, but that makes things complicated).
There is a setting in System Preferences > Dock called “Prefer tabs when opening documents”. Change this to “Manually”, it’s probably set to “Full Screen Only” mode right now.
Not sure why this setting is under the Dock preferences but this will fix your issue. Downside is I think all applications behave that way now, like Finder and Preview. I guess you can’t pick and choose specifically how you want an app to behave.
I turned it off because I am trained to use Cmd+N for new windows, and Cmd+T for tabs. It makes little sense why Cmd+N and Cmd+T would both open tabs regardless of settings. Why have the command execute from 2 different keyboard shortcuts, especially by wasting a classic shortcut that many have engrained in their heads.
agree 100%. this is the single reason i am not using bitwarden. if i can’t navigate using the keyboard, this app/extension is a non-starter.
To be fair, the desktop app is pretty feature-rich with shortcuts. The limitation is for the browser extensions, which tend to have only the basic shortcuts available. However, each browser has its own ability to add/modify shortcuts, so there are actually more available than what is mentioned in the online help - see here:
Yeh, who uses web browsers these days anyway?
“each browser has its own ability to add/modify shortcuts” - chrome lets you customise four shortcuts. Many (most?) of the common functions are missing:
This response completely misses a major point of the feature request. Keyboard navigation of the vault popup window is what I think most of us have been waiting for. That is, a quick way to open the vault, search, and then act on an item ALL without the mouse.
Way back in March 2018 I listed a proposed keyboard navigation workflow. Perhaps it’s worth reposting it…
- User-defined keyboard shortcut to open the extension (this already exists).
- On the extension, the default focus is search (this is already done as well).
- Pressing UP/DOWN should navigate the items list (the first item should automatically be highlighted)
- Pressing ENTER on an item should visit the site (or autofill if already open)
- Pressing RIGHT on an item should open the details pane for that item.
- Pressing ESC should close the popup.
On the details page:
- Pressing UP/DOWN should navigate the items for that entry.
- Pressing ENTER on an item should copy the value to the clipboard.
- Pressing LEFT should navigate back to the search pane.
- Pressing ESC should close the popup.
Hi @kriswilk - I think you may have misread my post. I was responding to @bunnyhero who was concerned that there was no way to navigate the desktop app because of a lack of shortcuts, as well as the browser extension. As I said, to be fair the desktop app has a lot of shortcuts available (see the link I posted). And the browser extension is definitely lacking, but there are more shortcuts than documented.
I wasn’t trying to delegitimize any requests regarding the web vault. Hope you can see that now!
@bunneyhero didn’t mention the desktop app, and the documentation = chrome shortcuts
Hi @bitmatron! Actually, yes he mentioned the app. And this whole thread is tagged for the desktop app (see the blue bar at the top - the tags are right below the thread title).
And if you look at the link I posted, I think you will see that the help page covers ALL browser extensions (not specific to Chrome, hence my remark about other possible shortcuts) as well as the Desktop App. Please have a look again - not sure how I can be more clear about this.
i mainly meant navigation, specifically using arrow keys in the extension. i mentioned the app because if the extension is useless to me i can’t use bitwarden at all. perhaps i should have written “service/extension”.
Thanks for clarifying, @bunnyhero. I agree that the extension is lacking - it is a harder fix given that BW is a slave to what individual browser developers dictate. Since you did mention the app, I thought perhaps you weren’t aware of all the shortcuts available. Makes sense now. Cheers!
@dh024 perhaps you can clarify if you are part of the Bitwarden team or just an active community member? I would really like someone from Bitwarden to address what is (I think) the primary focus of most of the discussion here. Namely, keyboard navigation in the browser extension.
Whether you speak for Bitwarden or not, any reference to how “hard” this is to do is going to fall on deaf ears. Lastpass had this figured out before Bitwarden even existed. Now, 4 years since it was formally requested (LONGER, since it was a Github issue well before this community existed), there’s been no progress.
The truth is, I’m unlikely to switch back to Lastpass or any other service JUST because of this (although some users have!). But I sure will think twice before recommending it to others.
Nope, I don’t work for Bitwarden. My only affiliation with them is as a customer. I received a lot of great advice from the community forums here when I started using Bitwarden, so I just try to pay it forward by helping out here as another community member.
Regarding the implementation of this feature request, I know it is technically possible. But remember that Bitwarden is still a fledgling product with a tiny development team compared to the big guys like Lastpass or 1Password. There are well over 2000 feature requests on this forum, so I assume the BW devs are prioritizing implementation and new development very carefully. So it is going to take some time to grow and get to everything, unfortunately. Having said that, they seem to be making great progress and are churning out a better and more fully featured product each release at a solid pace, so I am very happy to support them, even if there is a lot of polishing left to do. Cheers!
When the original issue was created there were no shortcuts at all in the desktop app (except for the ones handled by the OS). That’s why the github issue and my initial post here both mention some of shortcuts like copy username / password. Just now I learned that many of these have been implemented in the mean time, but you need to read through every single comment here to actually hear about this.
This brings me to a point which I wanted to make back when the browser extension was merged with this issue, but I just couldn’t be bothered because I had almost given up on bitwarden already: This feature is just too large to be fixed. By combining the browser extension and desktop issue into a single one it became nearly “unfixable”, especially given everyone understands something different under it, so whatever is being implemented someone will always think that this is not enough.
Maybe it would be time to split this feature request into smaller chunks which can actually be worked on? The fact the issue about not being able to copy username / password has been fixed by now (Basic keyboard shortcuts - #3) shows this point pretty well…
Also huge thanks @dh024 for linking the keyboard shortcuts. I wasn’t even aware that these shortcuts have been implemented by now, so I never bothered to look at Bitwarden again in the past 4 years.
Sadly it seems like I can’t even edit the original post now, so I can’t even link to the keyboard shortcuts for people who stumble over this feature request…