Ability to create profiles that have limited access to selected accounts/passwords

I’d like the ability to create profiles that have limited access to selected accounts/passwords.
Lastpass calls them “Identities.”

When I’m logged into my work computer, as an example, I would like some of the passwords available, but not everything. Switching profiles should be like logging out/in and require 2FA.

Possible duplicate of Log in with multiple Bitwarden user accounts

Linked accounts are different than the identity profiles.

Linked accounts is, as it sounds, linking two accounts together. My request is for separate profiles within the account that you can log into.

I like the idea. I’d never though of it though. It is not uncommon for users that don’t work at home to face this issue. It would add some extra security. I love it.

Huge fan of LastPass profiles - perfect for families that want limited passwords on their tablets in the children’s playroom and don’t want to worry about that device having full access to all of your passwords, and also don’t want to have to setup a separate bitwarden account for each device and then manage sharing - that’s not what we’re asking for here.

However, LastPass has downgraded the security around profiles to useless - they continually fail to understand the fundamental security distinction between using something and administrating that something.

I don’t want a separate account for my kids’ phones because when they create a new account and use Bitwarden as they would be trained to do so that they will be future secure password managers when they grown up, the new website and password are assigned to their separate account and is not automatically synchronized or granted control to my account.

With separate accounts, they are … separate - what’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours. As a parent, I don’t want my kid setting up “finsta” or “fakebook” accounts under their separate Bitwarden account and I have 1) no access to it or to know about it, 2) no way to know who they share them to - did they just share their bank account password? did they not use Bitwarden and used really poor account/password security? and 3) no way to ensure that they are backed up when I backup my account.

And worst of all, they could disconnect the account from the shared folder by copying it into their own account folder and then changing the password so that the password my shared folder knows about was changed.

With profiles, one has a separate PROFILE for each device. Each device is given direct access only to the specific entries visible to that profile - it’s like a filter applied to your vault - for that device/profile.

Now here is where LastPass gets it wrong - if you know your LastPass password (or PIN - or worse - fingerprint) - you can change your device profile to anything else you’d like - including “upgrading” your access from a limited “Netflix-only Toddler Tablet” to complete full account access (the “full” profile). Think about that when the device is set to allow USE of Bitwarden with a simple PIN or a fingerprint - and then allowing that same authentication method to “upgrade” the device profile to full access to all of your passwords belong to us.

Knowing a PIN or having a fingerprint that unlocks a device to USE the device is not at all the same as being the account owner and demonstrating you own the account.

They used to require the entry of the master password to change the profile, so that effectively, you could set the tablet/phone device to the restricted profile, allow USE with a PIN, but for the device to change any security feature (like changing the profile!) required the master password to be entered.

I said “used to”. The way it works now, is that if you can use LastPass to get to your passwords, you can change any security feature of the account. Anyone with access to your phone or tablet that can access LastPass has complete control and access to your account - up to and including changing the master password itself!

Threat model: You let me use your phone to make a phone call, so you unlock it and let me use it. I add my fingerprint to the phone’s authenticated user fingerprints. If you have “Fingerprint unlock” – for any application, including LastPass and banking apps – I have full access to them as well to grant additional devices and accounts full access to your Bitwarden vault.

So please get this one right, Bitwarden.

2 Likes

It would be nice to have profiles.

A simple example could be work. I have a “Work” folder for all work-related passwords. When using the Bitwarden Chrome extension I would like to filter work-related passwords (those in “Work” folder) only, not to bring the possibility to unlock all my passwords.

Yes. 1Password do this by having separate vaults, so I can have a work vault, a private vault and a family vault say, and manage them all, but some users are only granted access to one vault.

@mike808 makes an excellent point about administering an account/vault: the manager (parent in my case) needs to be able to make changes, whereas my children need to be able to access their area/vault/account, but not to be able to make changes.

1 Like

This a 100 times! I already use 7 different browser profiles depending on the use case (e.g., banking, social networks, etc.) and it would be nice to also have 7 different sub-vaults under my main account. Of course you could register 7 separate Bitwarden accounts, but to use advanced 2FA you would then have to pay for 7 premium accounts …

Currently it’s easier to keep some of the passwords outside Bitwarden stored in the browser’s password manager (cloud synchronized with E2E encryption, i.e., synch passphrase).

1 Like

I don’t like that I expose my banking/email credentials whenever I log in on some random device when I need a password on-site. Similar to making an organisation and adding extra accounts that only have access to a limited subset of collections, I would like to organise my data into collections that a sub identity has access to.

How would we find out if this functionality is possible/likely from bitwarden?

1 Like