Persistent Bitwarden UI and maintain unsaved data

When I add or edit an entry in the Web-Vault and accidental click outside of the edit window, then the edit window is closed without asking me if the changes should be saved (this happened several times to me, especially when I have multiple browser tabs opened and switch between Bitwarden and web apps where I want to change my login data).

So here I have a data loss (that must be prevented under the aspects of the usability).
I am not sure if this is a “normal” feature request or better a bug in GitHub!

1 Like

Yeah, it does this by default. Use the pop-out button top left and it becomes persistent.

I always do this when filling in a new one.

I am talking about the Web-Vault (https://vault.bitwarden.com/) not the browser extension (I enter new entries / edit existing entries normally in the Web-Vault).
And here I have no “pop-out” Button.

But if this same problem is also existing in the Browser Extension and users are forced to pop-out the window to prevent data loss, then this really has to be fixed!

There is already a request for this with several votes, please add your vote and comments there:

https://community.bitwarden.com/t/unsaved-changes-are-lost-when-move-to-another-item/5470

Thenk you @MarkMGB Voting for the other topic.

+1

Not sure what’s the logic of current UX given that losing user data should always a no-go.

In LastPass this has been a non-issue since forever, so reasons such as “This is not possible since the browser controls when that window closes” are moot. Just copy the behavior: open up a new tab with the page for creating a new Login, and move all already entered data to that new tab:

This is clearly a popular request, given the number of similar or related issues:

8 Likes

We’ve got this on our backlog to improve - we want to avoid data loss (for both browser and web vault items).

2 Likes

Dear Team of Bitwarden,

I recently got to know about bitwarden and really appreciate the software. In order to further improve on the user experience I would like to suggest a better way of handling the input of login details.

I would often open the bitwarden extension in my browser in order to save a new login. Most of the time I need to input my login name / email and a password.
Usually I type my username into the extension and then continue with the password.
When I open a different application for reference, like Mail or Textedit, copy the password to clipboard and switch back to the browser extension the already typed information (username) is lost. This happens every time I switch to a different application.

I would very much appreciate if bitwarden extensions could stay open and the login credentials would not be lost in the progress.

I am on macOS 10.15.7 running Safari 14 and Chrome 86

Yes, this is something that always bugged me. One other problem related to this: You can open the extension in a new window but then also all info typed in is lost and the URL-field gets filled in with a useless “chrome-extension://…” URL.

Edit: Maybe you could add an option that clicking the plus for a new login always opens Bitwarden in a new window (not tab) with the correct URL passed in. This way you can’t loose information and have the ability to even switch tabs.

1 Like

I guess this is a duplicate of Unsaved changes are lost when move to another item

Im going to add that this loss of focus makes it extremely frustrating when you have to switch to something else to grab a totp or security code on login with the extension. Once it loses focus you have to start all over again.

3 Likes

I’m new to Bitwarden, but see from these posts that this problem has been going on for over 2-years, and presents a very frustrating user experience. Please fix it! At the very least, please add a simple persistence time delay to the Edit panel; but it really needs a rock-solid Save or Cancel dialog.

Thank you!

2 Likes

A browser extension limitation prevents fixing this at this time. I can’t find the code snippet atm that shows this particular issue. I keep accidentally doing this myself, an option to force open in a new tab/side-panel/window when clicking edit would be a nice workaround until a better API is available.

1 Like

These two suggestions are essentially the same, and I think this would be a huge improvement - if you try to add a new item from the popup, it could automatically force BW into a new window or sidebar. That would be immensely helpful.

If you use FireFox currently, opening Bitwarden in the sidebar is definitely the best thing to do when adding new items - but as others have mentioned, it is easy to forget to do.

I have this issue too, and it’s very frustrating.

I was creating a new password. I clicked on another tab to get info to copy/paste into bitwarden, but clicking on another tab in chrome closes the Bitwarden extension and loses all typed data.

One idea is to keep the bitwarden extension window open, or at least save all progress so that once I click the bitwarden extension icon, it brings me back where I was with all the same data.

… add the new credentials or the new password only to Bitwarden BEFORE you do it on the website or in the app.

… to click the arrow to get a pop-out that will stay even if you follow the urge to switch to a different tab.

I’ve switched to Bitwarden a few months ago and recently added TOTP for some critical websites and overall really enjoy the experience. But this issue right here has a high priority in my opinion, since I almost forgot to update a TOTP code that could have become problematic for getting locked out of an account permanently. Luckily I realized and fixed it, but if I slept less hours I might have forgotten about it.

But overall Bitwarden is really amazing, especially that all of it is open source, and I am very happy to pay $10 a year to help Bitwarden :slight_smile:

Do not close opened entry while I’m copying login/password to website or credit card data. After coping just 1 thing I need to search it again.

Same for the creating an entry, if I need to copy all data from a website I have to focus on a website, which will close bitwarden’s plugin window and reset the filled form.

When I have to copy things from an item selectively and I go back to the browser extension after clicking off it, the item I was last viewing has gone, this slows me down and makes manual selective filling more difficult.

Feature name

  • Controllable ‘auto close’ behavior on browser

Feature function

  • Give user option to NOT automatically close the browser popup when clicking over to anything else

  • Current behavior makes it really annoying when you have multiple steps involved and are not (or cannot) use the right click menu. (Various reasons for that, including in many cases using the browser plugin for credential access for other windows outside of the browser.)

  • Current behavior is particularly annoying when copying data INTO bitwarden as you can’t do it in one session. I wind up having to save a partial entry, then find and edit, make partial update, repeat - if there are several copy/pastes involved. Really annoying, especially when you click off by mistake and it throws away your entire entry.

  • ALTERNATIVE IMPLEMENTATION: Retain the “last dialog” in BW plugin including any partially entered data. Have a quick dropdown option at the top of the BW menu to bring up the last thing you were looking at - including an unsaved new create/edit entry. This would not be as nice as just being able to tell BW “don’t close unless I tell you to close” - but it would be a huge improvement over current behavior.

Related topics + references

  • This behavior is supported by LastPass and is one of the only major pain points I’ve had moving away from LP to BW.
  • Yes, I am aware of being able to pop out and of the desktop app, but it’s an extra step, and request here is specifically about usability of the plugin within browser.
3 Likes